Want to lose weight? You’ve probably heard the same advice over and over: cardio burns calories, strength training builds muscle. But which one actually gets you results? And if you’re doing just one, are you leaving money on the table?
Let’s cut through the noise. In 2025, we know better than to pick sides. The real answer isn’t cardio or strength - it’s cardio and strength. But how much of each? And why does it matter? Here’s what the science, real people, and decades of clinical data actually say.
Cardio Burns Calories Fast - But Only While You’re Doing It
Cardio is the quick hitter. Run for 30 minutes? You’ll burn 300-400 calories. Cycle hard? Up to 600. Swim laps? Around 400. That’s real, measurable energy use. If your goal is to see the scale drop fast, cardio delivers.
But here’s the catch: as soon as you stop moving, the calorie burn stops too. Your body doesn’t keep burning extra calories hours later like it does after lifting weights. That’s why people hit plateaus. After 8-12 weeks of steady jogging or cycling, your body adapts. You’re not burning more than you did at week two, even if you’re doing the same workout longer.
And there’s another hidden cost: cardio, especially long, slow sessions, can eat into muscle if you’re not eating enough protein. One 2022 study found people who only did cardio lost 0.3kg of muscle over six months - even while losing fat. That’s not just a number. It’s slower metabolism, weaker joints, and less energy in daily life.
Strength Training Doesn’t Burn Much During the Workout - But It Changes Your Body Forever
Thirty minutes of lifting? You might burn only 90-150 calories. That feels like a rip-off if you’re comparing it to a run. But here’s what no one tells you: strength training wakes up your metabolism for up to 48 hours after you finish.
This is called EPOC - excess post-exercise oxygen consumption. Think of it as your body cleaning up the mess you made during the workout. It needs oxygen, energy, and nutrients to repair muscle, balance hormones, and restore systems. All of that burns calories. And the more muscle you have, the more your body burns at rest.
One kilogram of muscle burns 13-15 calories a day just sitting there. Fat? Only 4.5-5. So if you gain 2kg of muscle, you’re burning an extra 20-30 calories every single day - without doing a single rep. That’s 7,300-10,950 extra calories a year. That’s almost 1.5kg of fat.
And here’s the kicker: strength training reshapes your body even if the scale doesn’t move. People report clothes fitting better, waistlines shrinking, and looking leaner - even when they gain a pound or two. That’s because muscle is denser than fat. You’re not getting smaller - you’re getting tighter, stronger, more defined.
The Real Winner? Doing Both - And Doing Them Right
Let’s look at the data that matters: the 2022 Obesity journal study with 120 participants over six months. Three groups:
- Cardio only: lost 9.7% body fat, lost 0.3kg muscle
- Strength only: lost 7.1% body fat, gained 2.3kg muscle
- Cardio + strength: lost 12.4% body fat, gained 1.8kg muscle
That’s not a close race. The combo group lost more fat and gained muscle. The others? One lost muscle. One barely budged on fat. The science is clear: combining both gives you the best of both worlds.
And it’s not just lab results. Real people on Reddit, MyFitnessPal, and weight loss forums confirm it. Those who did both cardio and strength training were 37% more likely to keep the weight off after 18 months. The people who stuck with just one? Half of them regained it.
How Much Should You Actually Do?
You don’t need to spend five hours a week in the gym. The American College of Sports Medicine says this works:
- 150 minutes of moderate cardio per week - that’s 30 minutes, five days a week. Brisk walking, cycling, dancing - anything that gets your heart up but lets you talk.
- 120 minutes of strength training per week - that’s two full-body sessions of 60 minutes, or three 40-minute sessions.
For beginners? Start slower. Do 20 minutes of cardio three times a week and two 20-minute strength sessions. Focus on form, not weight. Learn how to squat, push, pull, and hinge before you load up.
Progression is everything. In strength training, if you’re not increasing the weight, reps, or sets every 1-2 weeks, you’re not growing. Most beginners fail here - they stay stuck at the same dumbbells for months. That’s why they see no change.
And protein? You need it. The International Society of Sports Nutrition recommends 1.6-2.2 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight daily. If you weigh 70kg, that’s 112-154 grams of protein a day. That’s not a shake and a chicken breast. That’s eggs, lean meat, tofu, Greek yogurt, cottage cheese, and legumes spread across meals.
What About HIIT? Is It the Secret Weapon?
High-intensity interval training (HIIT) - short bursts of max effort followed by rest - is a powerful middle ground. A 20-minute HIIT session can burn as many calories as 40 minutes of steady cardio. And it triggers 12-15% more EPOC than traditional cardio.
Try this: 30 seconds sprinting (or fast cycling, jumping jacks, burpees), 60 seconds walking. Repeat 8 times. Do it twice a week. You’ll get cardio benefits, muscle engagement, and metabolic boost - all in under 30 minutes.
But don’t replace all your cardio with HIIT. It’s brutal on the nervous system. Too much leads to burnout, injury, or adrenal fatigue. Use it as a tool, not your only weapon.
Why People Quit - And How to Stay On Track
Here’s what actually makes people drop out:
- Cardio users: Plateau after 8-12 weeks. The scale stops moving. They feel like they’re wasting time.
- Strength users: The scale goes up at first. They panic. They think they’re getting fat - but it’s water and muscle. They quit before the transformation kicks in.
- Everyone: Not tracking protein. Not progressing. Doing the same workout forever.
Fix this by measuring more than the scale. Take weekly photos. Measure your waist, hips, and arms. Notice how your clothes fit. Track energy levels. Sleep quality. Mood.
And don’t fall for the myth that you have to sweat buckets to lose weight. Walking 10,000 steps a day, taking the stairs, standing while you work - these non-exercise activities (NEAT) burn more calories daily than most people realize. A 2023 Mayo Clinic study showed NEAT contributes 2-3 times more to daily calorie burn than structured workouts.
What’s New in 2025? Personalized Training Is Here
Wearables are getting smarter. Garmin’s Body Battery, Apple Watch’s new Workout app, and Fitbit’s metabolic rate estimates now track your EPOC and calorie burn more accurately than ever.
And research is moving toward personalization. The NIH’s PREDICT 2 study is testing whether your genes tell you whether you’ll lose fat better with cardio or strength. Early results suggest some people respond 40% better to one over the other based on their DNA.
But you don’t need a DNA test. Just try both for 8 weeks. Track your results. See what makes you feel stronger, leaner, more energized. That’s your answer.
Bottom Line: Stop Choosing. Start Combining.
Cardio gets you out of the starting gate. Strength keeps you going long-term. One burns calories now. The other builds a body that burns calories forever.
Do 3-4 days of cardio. Do 2-3 days of strength. Eat enough protein. Sleep well. Move more outside the gym. That’s not a complicated plan. It’s the only one that works for real people over real time.
If you’ve been doing only one - switch. Add the other. Your body will thank you in ways the scale never could.
Is cardio or strength training better for losing belly fat?
Neither one targets belly fat directly - fat loss happens across the whole body. But combining cardio and strength training gives you the best shot. Cardio burns the most calories upfront, while strength training increases your resting metabolism, helping you burn fat even when you’re not working out. Studies show people who do both lose more abdominal fat than those who do just one.
Can I lose weight with strength training alone?
Yes, but it’s slower. Strength training alone can lead to modest fat loss - around 7% in 6 months - while building muscle. But without cardio, you won’t burn as many calories during workouts. That means you’ll need to be stricter with your diet to create a calorie deficit. Most people find it easier to lose weight with both cardio and strength training together.
Why does the scale go up when I start lifting weights?
Muscle holds more water than fat, and when you start strength training, your muscles store extra glycogen and water to repair and grow. This causes a temporary weight gain - usually 1-3 pounds - in the first few weeks. It’s not fat. It’s your body adapting. If you keep going, the scale will drop again as fat burns off and your body becomes leaner.
How often should I do cardio and strength training to lose weight?
Aim for 150 minutes of moderate cardio (like brisk walking or cycling) spread over 3-5 days, and 120 minutes of strength training (2-3 full-body sessions) per week. If you’re new, start with 2-3 days of each. The key is consistency, not intensity. You don’t need to train hard every day - just show up regularly.
Do I need to do HIIT to lose weight?
No, but it can help. HIIT burns more calories in less time and boosts your metabolism longer than steady cardio. But it’s not necessary. You can lose weight with brisk walking and basic strength training. HIIT is great if you’re short on time or hitting a plateau - but it’s not a magic bullet. Overdoing it can lead to burnout or injury.
What’s the most common mistake people make when trying to lose weight with exercise?
They think exercise alone is enough. Most people overestimate how many calories they burn and underestimate how many they eat. You can’t out-exercise a bad diet. The biggest success stories combine smart training with consistent, balanced eating - especially enough protein to protect muscle. Tracking food intake for even a few weeks makes a huge difference.
Comments(13)